Parsing the Behavioral and Brain Mechanisms of Third-Party Punishment
The evolved capacity for third-party punishment is considered crucial to the emergence and maintenance of elaborate human social organization and is central to the modern provision of fairness and justice within society. Although it is well established that the mental state of the offender and the s...
Gespeichert in:
| Veröffentlicht in: | The Journal of neuroscience Jg. 36; H. 36; S. 9420 - 9434 |
|---|---|
| Hauptverfasser: | , , , , , , |
| Format: | Journal Article |
| Sprache: | Englisch |
| Veröffentlicht: |
United States
07.09.2016
|
| Schlagworte: | |
| ISSN: | 1529-2401 |
| Online-Zugang: | Weitere Angaben |
| Tags: |
Tag hinzufügen
Keine Tags, Fügen Sie den ersten Tag hinzu!
|
| Abstract | The evolved capacity for third-party punishment is considered crucial to the emergence and maintenance of elaborate human social organization and is central to the modern provision of fairness and justice within society. Although it is well established that the mental state of the offender and the severity of the harm he caused are the two primary predictors of punishment decisions, the precise cognitive and brain mechanisms by which these distinct components are evaluated and integrated into a punishment decision are poorly understood. Using fMRI, here we implement a novel experimental design to functionally dissociate the mechanisms underlying evaluation, integration, and decision that were conflated in previous studies of third-party punishment. Behaviorally, the punishment decision is primarily defined by a superadditive interaction between harm and mental state, with subjects weighing the interaction factor more than the single factors of harm and mental state. On a neural level, evaluation of harms engaged brain areas associated with affective and somatosensory processing, whereas mental state evaluation primarily recruited circuitry involved in mentalization. Harm and mental state evaluations are integrated in medial prefrontal and posterior cingulate structures, with the amygdala acting as a pivotal hub of the interaction between harm and mental state. This integrated information is used by the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex at the time of the decision to assign an appropriate punishment through a distributed coding system. Together, these findings provide a blueprint of the brain mechanisms by which neutral third parties render punishment decisions.
Punishment undergirds large-scale cooperation and helps dispense criminal justice. Yet it is currently unknown precisely how people assess the mental states of offenders, evaluate the harms they caused, and integrate those two components into a single punishment decision. Using a new design, we isolated these three processes, identifying the distinct brain systems and activities that enable each. Additional findings suggest that the amygdala plays a crucial role in mediating the interaction of mental state and harm information, whereas the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex plays a crucial, final-stage role, both in integrating mental state and harm information and in selecting a suitable punishment amount. These findings deepen our understanding of how punishment decisions are made, which may someday help to improve them. |
|---|---|
| AbstractList | UNLABELLEDThe evolved capacity for third-party punishment is considered crucial to the emergence and maintenance of elaborate human social organization and is central to the modern provision of fairness and justice within society. Although it is well established that the mental state of the offender and the severity of the harm he caused are the two primary predictors of punishment decisions, the precise cognitive and brain mechanisms by which these distinct components are evaluated and integrated into a punishment decision are poorly understood. Using fMRI, here we implement a novel experimental design to functionally dissociate the mechanisms underlying evaluation, integration, and decision that were conflated in previous studies of third-party punishment. Behaviorally, the punishment decision is primarily defined by a superadditive interaction between harm and mental state, with subjects weighing the interaction factor more than the single factors of harm and mental state. On a neural level, evaluation of harms engaged brain areas associated with affective and somatosensory processing, whereas mental state evaluation primarily recruited circuitry involved in mentalization. Harm and mental state evaluations are integrated in medial prefrontal and posterior cingulate structures, with the amygdala acting as a pivotal hub of the interaction between harm and mental state. This integrated information is used by the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex at the time of the decision to assign an appropriate punishment through a distributed coding system. Together, these findings provide a blueprint of the brain mechanisms by which neutral third parties render punishment decisions.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENTPunishment undergirds large-scale cooperation and helps dispense criminal justice. Yet it is currently unknown precisely how people assess the mental states of offenders, evaluate the harms they caused, and integrate those two components into a single punishment decision. Using a new design, we isolated these three processes, identifying the distinct brain systems and activities that enable each. Additional findings suggest that the amygdala plays a crucial role in mediating the interaction of mental state and harm information, whereas the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex plays a crucial, final-stage role, both in integrating mental state and harm information and in selecting a suitable punishment amount. These findings deepen our understanding of how punishment decisions are made, which may someday help to improve them. The evolved capacity for third-party punishment is considered crucial to the emergence and maintenance of elaborate human social organization and is central to the modern provision of fairness and justice within society. Although it is well established that the mental state of the offender and the severity of the harm he caused are the two primary predictors of punishment decisions, the precise cognitive and brain mechanisms by which these distinct components are evaluated and integrated into a punishment decision are poorly understood. Using fMRI, here we implement a novel experimental design to functionally dissociate the mechanisms underlying evaluation, integration, and decision that were conflated in previous studies of third-party punishment. Behaviorally, the punishment decision is primarily defined by a superadditive interaction between harm and mental state, with subjects weighing the interaction factor more than the single factors of harm and mental state. On a neural level, evaluation of harms engaged brain areas associated with affective and somatosensory processing, whereas mental state evaluation primarily recruited circuitry involved in mentalization. Harm and mental state evaluations are integrated in medial prefrontal and posterior cingulate structures, with the amygdala acting as a pivotal hub of the interaction between harm and mental state. This integrated information is used by the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex at the time of the decision to assign an appropriate punishment through a distributed coding system. Together, these findings provide a blueprint of the brain mechanisms by which neutral third parties render punishment decisions. Punishment undergirds large-scale cooperation and helps dispense criminal justice. Yet it is currently unknown precisely how people assess the mental states of offenders, evaluate the harms they caused, and integrate those two components into a single punishment decision. Using a new design, we isolated these three processes, identifying the distinct brain systems and activities that enable each. Additional findings suggest that the amygdala plays a crucial role in mediating the interaction of mental state and harm information, whereas the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex plays a crucial, final-stage role, both in integrating mental state and harm information and in selecting a suitable punishment amount. These findings deepen our understanding of how punishment decisions are made, which may someday help to improve them. |
| Author | Marois, René Ginther, Matthew R Bonnie, Richard J Shen, Francis X Jones, Owen D Simons, Kenneth W Hoffman, Morris B |
| Author_xml | – sequence: 1 givenname: Matthew R orcidid: 0000-0001-8109-0914 surname: Ginther fullname: Ginther, Matthew R email: ginther@gmail.com, owen.jones@vanderbilt.edu, ginther@gmail.com, rene.marois@vanderbilt.edu organization: Neuroscience Graduate Program, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee 37203, Vanderbilt Law School, Nashville, Tennessee 37203, ginther@gmail.com owen.jones@vanderbilt.edu ginther@gmail.com rene.marois@vanderbilt.edu – sequence: 2 givenname: Richard J orcidid: 0000-0003-2945-7699 surname: Bonnie fullname: Bonnie, Richard J organization: Institute of Law, Psychiatry and Public Policy, University of Virginia School of Law, Charlottesville, Virginia 22903 – sequence: 3 givenname: Morris B orcidid: 0000-0002-2200-2010 surname: Hoffman fullname: Hoffman, Morris B organization: District Judge, Second Judicial District (Denver), State of Colorado, Denver, Colorado 80202 – sequence: 4 givenname: Francis X orcidid: 0000-0002-9029-1686 surname: Shen fullname: Shen, Francis X organization: Department of Law, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55455 – sequence: 5 givenname: Kenneth W orcidid: 0000-0003-2516-7379 surname: Simons fullname: Simons, Kenneth W organization: Department of Law, University of California, Irvine School of Law, Irvine, California 92697 – sequence: 6 givenname: Owen D orcidid: 0000-0002-9649-1005 surname: Jones fullname: Jones, Owen D email: ginther@gmail.com, owen.jones@vanderbilt.edu, ginther@gmail.com, rene.marois@vanderbilt.edu organization: Vanderbilt Law School, Nashville, Tennessee 37203, Departments of Law and Biological Sciences, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee 37203, Director, MacArthur Foundation Research Network on Law and Neuroscience, Center for Integrative and Cognitive Neuroscience, and ginther@gmail.com owen.jones@vanderbilt.edu ginther@gmail.com rene.marois@vanderbilt.edu – sequence: 7 givenname: René orcidid: 0000-0003-2998-4712 surname: Marois fullname: Marois, René email: ginther@gmail.com, owen.jones@vanderbilt.edu, ginther@gmail.com, rene.marois@vanderbilt.edu organization: Center for Integrative and Cognitive Neuroscience, and Department of Psychology, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee 37240 ginther@gmail.com owen.jones@vanderbilt.edu ginther@gmail.com rene.marois@vanderbilt.edu |
| BackLink | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27605616$$D View this record in MEDLINE/PubMed |
| BookMark | eNo1j8tOwzAURC0Eog_4hcpLNin2tePES1oVKCq0gnYd3cQOCUqcEidI_XsiUVYjzZwZaSbk0jXOEjLjbM5DEPcvb6vD-_ZjuZ5LqXXAwzkwri7IeEh1AJLxEZl4_8UYixiPrskIIsVCxdWYrHbY-tJ90q6wdGEL_CmbFiuKztBFi6WjrzYr0JW-9rTJ6b4oWxMMpe5Ed_1gF7V13Q25yrHy9vasU3J4XO2Xz8Fm-7RePmyCLJTQBSg0QpjZLMqN0SbWLAILoeRRDqgjQGFxIJhUKQulMAKY4jLToPM0TjWHKbn72z22zXdvfZfUpc9sVaGzTe8THvNYCCU1DOjsjPZpbU1ybMsa21Pyfx1-AfG6W4c |
| CitedBy_id | crossref_primary_10_1093_cercor_bhae497 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_cortex_2019_03_024 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_ijpsycho_2022_04_003 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_biopsycho_2019_107722 crossref_primary_10_1038_s41598_021_93908_z crossref_primary_10_1073_pnas_2500730122 crossref_primary_10_1093_scan_nsac057 crossref_primary_10_1111_tops_12382 crossref_primary_10_1007_s12264_021_00808_3 crossref_primary_10_1093_brain_awy064 crossref_primary_10_3389_fpsyg_2022_803184 crossref_primary_10_1523_JNEUROSCI_1242_17_2018 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_neuropsychologia_2019_01_020 crossref_primary_10_1038_s41598_019_49239_1 crossref_primary_10_3389_fnhum_2017_00587 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_neuroimage_2021_118730 crossref_primary_10_1038_srep45967 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_joep_2023_102675 crossref_primary_10_1017_ajil_2017_97 crossref_primary_10_1038_s41598_019_48649_5 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_socec_2022_101872 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_neuroimage_2023_120468 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_brainresbull_2024_111082 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_isci_2025_111988 crossref_primary_10_1002_hbm_25648 crossref_primary_10_3389_fnhum_2017_00647 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_chb_2025_108640 crossref_primary_10_1038_s41562_021_01064_1 crossref_primary_10_1038_s41598_017_05299_9 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_neuroimage_2025_121133 crossref_primary_10_3389_fnins_2017_00374 crossref_primary_10_1007_s11682_021_00555_z crossref_primary_10_1038_s41386_021_01092_5 crossref_primary_10_1177_0146167220965306 crossref_primary_10_1007_s10548_023_01029_9 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_pscychresns_2022_111528 crossref_primary_10_3389_fnhum_2017_00512 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_neubiorev_2023_105525 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_neuroimage_2024_120613 crossref_primary_10_3758_s13415_019_00711_5 crossref_primary_10_3758_s13415_021_00927_4 |
| ContentType | Journal Article |
| Copyright | Copyright © 2016 Ginther et al. |
| Copyright_xml | – notice: Copyright © 2016 Ginther et al. |
| DBID | CGR CUY CVF ECM EIF NPM 7X8 |
| DOI | 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.4499-15.2016 |
| DatabaseName | Medline MEDLINE MEDLINE (Ovid) MEDLINE MEDLINE PubMed MEDLINE - Academic |
| DatabaseTitle | MEDLINE Medline Complete MEDLINE with Full Text PubMed MEDLINE (Ovid) MEDLINE - Academic |
| DatabaseTitleList | MEDLINE - Academic MEDLINE |
| Database_xml | – sequence: 1 dbid: NPM name: PubMed url: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?db=PubMed sourceTypes: Index Database – sequence: 2 dbid: 7X8 name: MEDLINE - Academic url: https://search.proquest.com/medline sourceTypes: Aggregation Database |
| DeliveryMethod | no_fulltext_linktorsrc |
| Discipline | Anatomy & Physiology |
| EISSN | 1529-2401 |
| EndPage | 9434 |
| ExternalDocumentID | 27605616 |
| Genre | Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't Journal Article |
| GroupedDBID | --- -DZ -~X .55 18M 2WC 34G 39C 53G 5GY 5RE 5VS AAFWJ AAJMC ABBAR ABIVO ACGUR ACNCT ADBBV ADCOW ADHGD AENEX AFCFT AFOSN AFSQR AHWXS ALMA_UNASSIGNED_HOLDINGS AOIJS BAWUL BTFSW CGR CS3 CUY CVF DIK DU5 E3Z EBS ECM EIF EJD F5P GX1 H13 HYE H~9 KQ8 L7B NPM OK1 P0W P2P QZG R.V RHI RPM TFN TR2 W8F WH7 WOQ X7M XJT YBU YHG YKV YNH YSK 7X8 ABUFD |
| ID | FETCH-LOGICAL-c542t-a39a25cec7fdd9d89072e25417f2a972a3ea9a2046b0543d320614c929fb8b912 |
| IEDL.DBID | 7X8 |
| ISICitedReferencesCount | 53 |
| ISICitedReferencesURI | http://www.webofscience.com/api/gateway?GWVersion=2&SrcApp=Summon&SrcAuth=ProQuest&DestLinkType=CitingArticles&DestApp=WOS_CPL&KeyUT=000384006300015&url=https%3A%2F%2Fcvtisr.summon.serialssolutions.com%2F%23%21%2Fsearch%3Fho%3Df%26include.ft.matches%3Dt%26l%3Dnull%26q%3D |
| IngestDate | Sun Nov 09 14:02:43 EST 2025 Thu Apr 03 06:53:48 EDT 2025 |
| IsDoiOpenAccess | false |
| IsOpenAccess | true |
| IsPeerReviewed | true |
| IsScholarly | true |
| Issue | 36 |
| Keywords | fMRI punishment law harm decision-making mental state |
| Language | English |
| License | Copyright © 2016 Ginther et al. |
| LinkModel | DirectLink |
| MergedId | FETCHMERGED-LOGICAL-c542t-a39a25cec7fdd9d89072e25417f2a972a3ea9a2046b0543d320614c929fb8b912 |
| Notes | ObjectType-Article-1 SourceType-Scholarly Journals-1 ObjectType-Feature-2 content type line 23 |
| ORCID | 0000-0003-2516-7379 0000-0003-2945-7699 0000-0002-2200-2010 0000-0003-2998-4712 0000-0002-9649-1005 0000-0001-8109-0914 0000-0002-9029-1686 |
| OpenAccessLink | https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1872272492578087552 |
| PMID | 27605616 |
| PQID | 1818336492 |
| PQPubID | 23479 |
| PageCount | 15 |
| ParticipantIDs | proquest_miscellaneous_1818336492 pubmed_primary_27605616 |
| PublicationCentury | 2000 |
| PublicationDate | 2016-09-07 20160907 |
| PublicationDateYYYYMMDD | 2016-09-07 |
| PublicationDate_xml | – month: 09 year: 2016 text: 2016-09-07 day: 07 |
| PublicationDecade | 2010 |
| PublicationPlace | United States |
| PublicationPlace_xml | – name: United States |
| PublicationTitle | The Journal of neuroscience |
| PublicationTitleAlternate | J Neurosci |
| PublicationYear | 2016 |
| References | 28706474 - Front Neurosci. 2017 Jun 29;11:374 |
| References_xml | – reference: 28706474 - Front Neurosci. 2017 Jun 29;11:374 |
| SSID | ssj0007017 |
| Score | 2.4570086 |
| Snippet | The evolved capacity for third-party punishment is considered crucial to the emergence and maintenance of elaborate human social organization and is central to... UNLABELLEDThe evolved capacity for third-party punishment is considered crucial to the emergence and maintenance of elaborate human social organization and is... |
| SourceID | proquest pubmed |
| SourceType | Aggregation Database Index Database |
| StartPage | 9420 |
| SubjectTerms | Adolescent Adult Brain - diagnostic imaging Brain - physiology Brain Mapping Decision Making - physiology Female Humans Image Processing, Computer-Assisted Magnetic Resonance Imaging Male Oxygen - blood Punishment - psychology Theory of Mind - physiology Time Factors Young Adult |
| Title | Parsing the Behavioral and Brain Mechanisms of Third-Party Punishment |
| URI | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27605616 https://www.proquest.com/docview/1818336492 |
| Volume | 36 |
| WOSCitedRecordID | wos000384006300015&url=https%3A%2F%2Fcvtisr.summon.serialssolutions.com%2F%23%21%2Fsearch%3Fho%3Df%26include.ft.matches%3Dt%26l%3Dnull%26q%3D |
| hasFullText | |
| inHoldings | 1 |
| isFullTextHit | |
| isPrint | |
| link | http://cvtisr.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/link/0/eLvHCXMwpV3NS8MwFA_qPHjxa37MLyKIt7g1aZvkJHNsqLBScMJuI01StsPauU5h_70vXedOguClp6aU19eX3--938tD6K6V2kCbliDWcyPMFDMkUaElInRZD-Yr7pty2ASPIjEcyrhKuBWVrHIdE8tAbXLtcuRN2IkEY6Ev6ePsg7ipUa66Wo3Q2EY1BlDGSbr4cHNaOAd3q7qCgW81XyOnjnvrvDz4gPOJFzhlV_g7tCy3mN7Bf1_uEO1X4BK3V95whLZsdozq7QyI9XSJ73Ep9yzz6HXUjVWZJ8CAAPHTT7M-VpnBT25uBO5b1xU8KaYFzlM8GE_mhsCixRLHrgY-dnnFE_Te6w46z6SaqUB04NMFUUwqGmireWqMNAK4MbVAEj2eUiU5VcwquANYcwJgjhlGHWXUAKLSRCTSo6doJ8sze45wKj14imAqBNAluBEpUxCyrEws15rLBrpdG2sEPusKESqz-Wcx2pirgc5WFh_NVodrjCgPHakJL_6w-hLtuS9YSr74Faql8Mfaa7SrvxaTYn5TOgNco7j_DX28vz8 |
| linkProvider | ProQuest |
| openUrl | ctx_ver=Z39.88-2004&ctx_enc=info%3Aofi%2Fenc%3AUTF-8&rfr_id=info%3Asid%2Fsummon.serialssolutions.com&rft_val_fmt=info%3Aofi%2Ffmt%3Akev%3Amtx%3Ajournal&rft.genre=article&rft.atitle=Parsing+the+Behavioral+and+Brain+Mechanisms+of+Third-Party+Punishment&rft.jtitle=The+Journal+of+neuroscience&rft.au=Ginther%2C+Matthew+R&rft.au=Bonnie%2C+Richard+J&rft.au=Hoffman%2C+Morris+B&rft.au=Shen%2C+Francis+X&rft.date=2016-09-07&rft.eissn=1529-2401&rft.volume=36&rft.issue=36&rft.spage=9420&rft.epage=9434&rft_id=info:doi/10.1523%2FJNEUROSCI.4499-15.2016&rft.externalDBID=NO_FULL_TEXT |