Sen on Open and Closed Impartiality

In this article, I will rebut Amartya Sen's arguments that John Rawls's political philosophy gives us a form of closed rather than open impartiality. I will argue that there is plenty of room within Rawls's own theory of justice to accommodate the requirements of open impartiality. I...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Published in:Theoria (Pietermaritzburg) Vol. 72; no. 184; pp. 23 - 42
Main Author: Elmore, Benjamin
Format: Journal Article
Language:English
Published: 01.09.2025
ISSN:0040-5817, 1558-5816
Online Access:Get full text
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
Abstract In this article, I will rebut Amartya Sen's arguments that John Rawls's political philosophy gives us a form of closed rather than open impartiality. I will argue that there is plenty of room within Rawls's own theory of justice to accommodate the requirements of open impartiality. I will appeal to the way the original position is used in public reason and the method of reflective equilibrium to defend Rawls. Given the way that it fits into Rawls's broader theory, the original position should not be construed as a form of closed impartiality, doomed to be infected unduly by parochial cultural values. Rawls's contractualism is more defensible and versatile than Sen envisions. Some elements of Sen's argument have been briefly addressed before, but this article provides the only sustained, systematic treatment of this important issue.
AbstractList In this article, I will rebut Amartya Sen's arguments that John Rawls's political philosophy gives us a form of closed rather than open impartiality. I will argue that there is plenty of room within Rawls's own theory of justice to accommodate the requirements of open impartiality. I will appeal to the way the original position is used in public reason and the method of reflective equilibrium to defend Rawls. Given the way that it fits into Rawls's broader theory, the original position should not be construed as a form of closed impartiality, doomed to be infected unduly by parochial cultural values. Rawls's contractualism is more defensible and versatile than Sen envisions. Some elements of Sen's argument have been briefly addressed before, but this article provides the only sustained, systematic treatment of this important issue.
Author Elmore, Benjamin
Author_xml – sequence: 1
  givenname: Benjamin
  orcidid: 0000-0003-4734-2692
  surname: Elmore
  fullname: Elmore, Benjamin
BookMark eNotj7lqw0AURYfgQGTHdVpBasnvza4yiCwGg4u4H0azYBlZEho1_vtYxNW51eWcNVn1Qx8IeUMoGUq1m88lBSpKRVFzoE8kQyF0ITTKFckAOCxbvZB1ShcAZMhoRt5_Q58PfX4c77S9z-tuSMHn--top7m1XTvfXslztF0K2wc35PT1eap_isPxe19_HAqnkRZW2CoA9dEHLaVueBTOcSsbz6NEJR1XwK3gSnsGvoqVlpWr7q6NBcQQ2Ibs_m_dNKQ0hWjGqb3a6WYQzJJo5rNZEs0jkf0BvXFEiQ
ContentType Journal Article
DBID AAYXX
CITATION
DOI 10.3167/th.2025.7218402
DatabaseName CrossRef
DatabaseTitle CrossRef
DatabaseTitleList CrossRef
DeliveryMethod fulltext_linktorsrc
Discipline Social Sciences (General)
EISSN 1558-5816
EndPage 42
ExternalDocumentID 10_3167_th_2025_7218402
GroupedDBID 0R~
29Q
3D0
3LD
AAYXX
ABDBF
ABJNI
ACREJ
ADAAO
ADMHG
AEGXH
AELGQ
AHIZY
ALMA_UNASSIGNED_HOLDINGS
CITATION
CS3
EAP
ESI
ESX
FRS
GROUPED_DOAJ
H13
HZ~
IAO
IEA
ILR
IOF
ISE
O9-
OK1
P2P
QN7
RBG
RWL
RXW
TAE
TN5
V8K
ID FETCH-LOGICAL-c812-a5a9e02dfde8668b4f5cc4a6bd4f6176c4704a5478d30d9f9869c9184ba011ee3
ISSN 0040-5817
IngestDate Sat Nov 29 07:29:02 EST 2025
IsDoiOpenAccess false
IsOpenAccess true
IsPeerReviewed true
IsScholarly true
Issue 184
Language English
License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
LinkModel OpenURL
MergedId FETCHMERGED-LOGICAL-c812-a5a9e02dfde8668b4f5cc4a6bd4f6176c4704a5478d30d9f9869c9184ba011ee3
ORCID 0000-0003-4734-2692
OpenAccessLink https://doi.org/10.3167/th.2025.7218402
PageCount 20
ParticipantIDs crossref_primary_10_3167_th_2025_7218402
PublicationCentury 2000
PublicationDate 2025-09-01
PublicationDateYYYYMMDD 2025-09-01
PublicationDate_xml – month: 09
  year: 2025
  text: 2025-09-01
  day: 01
PublicationDecade 2020
PublicationTitle Theoria (Pietermaritzburg)
PublicationYear 2025
References Rawls, J. (bib6) 1997; 64
Wenar, L. (bib16) 2021
Rawls, J. (bib9) 2005
Boran, I. (bib1) 2004; 38
Golemboski, D. (bib3) 2018; 17
Souza, C. (bib14) 2018
Smith, A. (bib13) 2009
Valentini, L. (bib15) 2011; 27
Sen, A. (bib12) 2009
Clare, J. (bib2) 2010; 29
Rawls, J. (bib8) 1999b
Nussbaum, M. C. (bib5) 2015
Rawls, J. (bib7) 1999a
Hamilton, L. (bib4) 2019
Sen, A. (bib11) 2002; 99
Scanlon, T. M. (bib10) 2003
References_xml – year: 1999b
  ident: bib8
– volume: 27
  start-page: 297
  issue: 3
  year: 2011
  ident: bib15
  article-title: A Paradigm Shift in Theorizing about Justice? A Critique of Sen
– volume: 38
  start-page: 333
  year: 2004
  ident: bib1
  article-title: On Distinguishing between Types of Impartiality
– volume: 99
  start-page: 445
  issue: 9
  year: 2002
  ident: bib11
  article-title: Open and Closed Impartiality
– year: 2009
  ident: bib12
– year: 2005
  ident: bib9
– year: 2021
  ident: bib16
  article-title: John Rawls
– volume: 29
  start-page: 74
  issue: 2
  year: 2010
  ident: bib2
  article-title: Sen and Sensibility
– volume: 17
  start-page: 174
  issue: 2
  year: 2018
  ident: bib3
  article-title: The Impartiality of Smith's Spectator: The Problem of Parochialism and the Possibility of Social Critique
– start-page: 139
  year: 2003
  ident: bib10
  article-title: Rawls on Justification
– start-page: 1
  year: 2015
  ident: bib5
  article-title: Introduction
– start-page: 116
  year: 2018
  ident: bib14
  article-title: Equal Liberty, Reflective Equilibrium and Education: Defending Rawls from Sen's Criticisms
– year: 2009
  ident: bib13
– year: 2019
  ident: bib4
– volume: 64
  start-page: 765
  issue: 3
  year: 1997
  ident: bib6
  article-title: The Idea of Public Reason Revisited
– year: 1999a
  ident: bib7
SSID ssj0013132
Score 2.302126
Snippet In this article, I will rebut Amartya Sen's arguments that John Rawls's political philosophy gives us a form of closed rather than open impartiality. I will...
SourceID crossref
SourceType Index Database
StartPage 23
Title Sen on Open and Closed Impartiality
Volume 72
hasFullText 1
inHoldings 1
isFullTextHit
isPrint
journalDatabaseRights – providerCode: PRVAON
  databaseName: DOAJ Directory of Open Access Journals
  customDbUrl:
  eissn: 1558-5816
  dateEnd: 99991231
  omitProxy: false
  ssIdentifier: ssj0013132
  issn: 0040-5817
  databaseCode: DOA
  dateStart: 20210101
  isFulltext: true
  titleUrlDefault: https://www.doaj.org/
  providerName: Directory of Open Access Journals
link http://cvtisr.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/link/0/eLvHCXMwtV3NS8MwFA86PXgRP3F-EdCDHqpdm6TJUYeiICI4ZLeSr-JkdsNVEf96X9p0KwNBD15KCeXR5Ne-93t5H0HomCmpqbYsAGMNDgpQiEBligZGWxGZTkfJMpvw6S65v-f9vnjwJ2RPyuMEkjznn59i_K9QwxiA7Upn_wD3VCgMwD2ADleAHa6_Av7R5i4C4DJFyshAdziaAKu8dbnm8Ds72t1kpGVx_kA6pvkwKHNjwHsuvlz0pbFLcDWsE3Ivbf4iX32_br9dENFpPtRUBZIwoLwqmDyzXutRV35VFT3WajGJmvBz0tRyccNeVs2x5jWxK7CHlSpcvCeiZ0npSUYzo1MH2uds0TRDEHwTJyItnlMnIPUCFtFSlFAhat-5Dhd14qhOj3Rzq3o4OQHnc2_QoB8NHtFbQ6veAcAXFXDraMHmG6hdVUljr2kn-MS3Az_dREcAKB7l2AGKAVBcAYqbgG6h3vVVr3sT-KMtAg2MKpBUChtGJjOWM8YVyajWRDJlSAaUkmmShES6VmsmDo3IBGdCC5iAkqCPrY23USsf5XYHYcZlJqUyKswYEdIITRNrOTcJsTSmvI1O6gmn46qBSfrD4u7-_tE9tDL7uPZRq3h7twdoWX8Ug8nbYQnON-lNN0Y
linkProvider Directory of Open Access Journals
openUrl ctx_ver=Z39.88-2004&ctx_enc=info%3Aofi%2Fenc%3AUTF-8&rfr_id=info%3Asid%2Fsummon.serialssolutions.com&rft_val_fmt=info%3Aofi%2Ffmt%3Akev%3Amtx%3Ajournal&rft.genre=article&rft.atitle=Sen+on+Open+and+Closed+Impartiality&rft.jtitle=Theoria+%28Pietermaritzburg%29&rft.au=Elmore%2C+Benjamin&rft.date=2025-09-01&rft.issn=0040-5817&rft.eissn=1558-5816&rft.volume=72&rft.issue=184&rft.spage=23&rft.epage=42&rft_id=info:doi/10.3167%2Fth.2025.7218402&rft.externalDBID=n%2Fa&rft.externalDocID=10_3167_th_2025_7218402
thumbnail_l http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/lc.gif&issn=0040-5817&client=summon
thumbnail_m http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/mc.gif&issn=0040-5817&client=summon
thumbnail_s http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/sc.gif&issn=0040-5817&client=summon