Ten Reasons Why Prospective Randomized Studies in Surgery Are Flawed and Fundamentally Different From Drug Trials

Prospective randomized controlled trials are widely regarded as the gold standard for evaluating therapeutic interventions. Although this model is appropriate for drug development, its application in surgical research has proven challenging and, in many cases, misleading. Surgery involves complex in...

Ausführliche Beschreibung

Gespeichert in:
Bibliographische Detailangaben
Veröffentlicht in:The Journal of hand surgery (American ed.)
Hauptverfasser: Shin, Alexander Y, de Pinal, Francisco
Format: Journal Article
Sprache:Englisch
Veröffentlicht: United States 31.10.2025
Schlagworte:
Drug trials
prospective randomized studies in surgery
ISSN:1531-6564, 1531-6564
Online-Zugang:Weitere Angaben
Tags: Tag hinzufügen
Keine Tags, Fügen Sie den ersten Tag hinzu!
Abstract Prospective randomized controlled trials are widely regarded as the gold standard for evaluating therapeutic interventions. Although this model is appropriate for drug development, its application in surgical research has proven challenging and, in many cases, misleading. Surgery involves complex interactions between technical skill, patient variability, and intraoperative decision-making that cannot be easily standardized or controlled. This article outlines 10 reasons why prospective randomized studies in surgery are fundamentally different from drug trials, highlighting methodological, ethical, and practical concerns. Recognizing these distinctions is critical to developing more appropriate and context-sensitive research frameworks for surgical evaluation.
AbstractList Prospective randomized controlled trials are widely regarded as the gold standard for evaluating therapeutic interventions. Although this model is appropriate for drug development, its application in surgical research has proven challenging and, in many cases, misleading. Surgery involves complex interactions between technical skill, patient variability, and intraoperative decision-making that cannot be easily standardized or controlled. This article outlines 10 reasons why prospective randomized studies in surgery are fundamentally different from drug trials, highlighting methodological, ethical, and practical concerns. Recognizing these distinctions is critical to developing more appropriate and context-sensitive research frameworks for surgical evaluation.Prospective randomized controlled trials are widely regarded as the gold standard for evaluating therapeutic interventions. Although this model is appropriate for drug development, its application in surgical research has proven challenging and, in many cases, misleading. Surgery involves complex interactions between technical skill, patient variability, and intraoperative decision-making that cannot be easily standardized or controlled. This article outlines 10 reasons why prospective randomized studies in surgery are fundamentally different from drug trials, highlighting methodological, ethical, and practical concerns. Recognizing these distinctions is critical to developing more appropriate and context-sensitive research frameworks for surgical evaluation.
Prospective randomized controlled trials are widely regarded as the gold standard for evaluating therapeutic interventions. Although this model is appropriate for drug development, its application in surgical research has proven challenging and, in many cases, misleading. Surgery involves complex interactions between technical skill, patient variability, and intraoperative decision-making that cannot be easily standardized or controlled. This article outlines 10 reasons why prospective randomized studies in surgery are fundamentally different from drug trials, highlighting methodological, ethical, and practical concerns. Recognizing these distinctions is critical to developing more appropriate and context-sensitive research frameworks for surgical evaluation.
Author de Pinal, Francisco
Shin, Alexander Y
Author_xml – sequence: 1
  givenname: Alexander Y
  surname: Shin
  fullname: Shin, Alexander Y
  email: shin.alexander@mayo.edu
  organization: Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA. Electronic address: shin.alexander@mayo.edu
– sequence: 2
  givenname: Francisco
  surname: de Pinal
  fullname: de Pinal, Francisco
  organization: Private Practice, Madrid, Spain
BackLink https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/41171217$$D View this record in MEDLINE/PubMed
BookMark eNpNkM1OwzAQhC0Eoj_wAhyQj1wSvI6dtMeqJYBUCdQWcYxcZ9O6SpzWbkDh6QmiSGgPs6v9Zg4zIOe2tkjIDbAQGMT3u3C39SrkjMuQjUPGxmekDzKCIJaxOP-398jA-x1jnSuSl6QnABLgkPTJYYWWLlD52nr6vm3pq6v9HvXRfCBdKJvXlfnCnC6PTW7QU2PpsnEbdC2dOKRpqT67b8fRtLG5qtAeVVm2dGaKAl130dTVFZ25ZkNXzqjSX5GLohO8PumQvKUPq-lTMH95fJ5O5oEGKZIgFjkTQhQjENEaQAMwhZqLCKRURQSc8zwWEdciHxWo5CiJpI6x4DHXCes6GZK739y9qw8N-mNWGa-xLJXFuvFZxOPkZyDp0NsT2qwrzLO9M5VybfZXE_8GGGlr7g
ContentType Journal Article
Copyright Copyright © 2025 American Society for Surgery of the Hand. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Copyright_xml – notice: Copyright © 2025 American Society for Surgery of the Hand. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
DBID NPM
7X8
DOI 10.1016/j.jhsa.2025.09.009
DatabaseName PubMed
MEDLINE - Academic
DatabaseTitle PubMed
MEDLINE - Academic
DatabaseTitleList MEDLINE - Academic
PubMed
Database_xml – sequence: 1
  dbid: NPM
  name: PubMed
  url: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?db=PubMed
  sourceTypes: Index Database
– sequence: 2
  dbid: 7X8
  name: MEDLINE - Academic
  url: https://search.proquest.com/medline
  sourceTypes: Aggregation Database
DeliveryMethod no_fulltext_linktorsrc
EISSN 1531-6564
ExternalDocumentID 41171217
Genre Journal Article
Review
GroupedDBID ---
--K
.1-
.FO
0R~
123
1B1
1P~
1~5
4.4
457
4G.
7-5
AAEDT
AAEDW
AALRI
AAXUO
ABLJU
ABMAC
ADBBV
AEVXI
AFJKZ
AFRHN
AFTJW
AHHHB
AHMBA
AITUG
AJUYK
ALMA_UNASSIGNED_HOLDINGS
AMRAJ
APXCP
BELOY
CS3
EBS
EFJIC
EFKBS
F5P
FDB
G-Q
GBLVA
IHE
J1W
K-O
L7B
M41
NPM
O9-
OF0
OR.
PQQKQ
ROL
RPZ
RWL
SDG
SEL
SES
SEW
SJN
SSZ
TAE
UV1
XH2
Z5R
7X8
ID FETCH-LOGICAL-c1547-64d0444f8143b11c110aec243155af31222d6432c4d8fea58735c6ef262c70202
IEDL.DBID 7X8
ISSN 1531-6564
IngestDate Sat Nov 01 19:49:42 EDT 2025
Mon Nov 03 02:08:48 EST 2025
IsPeerReviewed true
IsScholarly true
Keywords Drug trials
prospective randomized studies in surgery
Language English
License Copyright © 2025 American Society for Surgery of the Hand. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
LinkModel DirectLink
MergedId FETCHMERGED-LOGICAL-c1547-64d0444f8143b11c110aec243155af31222d6432c4d8fea58735c6ef262c70202
Notes ObjectType-Article-1
SourceType-Scholarly Journals-1
ObjectType-Feature-2
ObjectType-Review-3
content type line 23
PMID 41171217
PQID 3267676717
PQPubID 23479
ParticipantIDs proquest_miscellaneous_3267676717
pubmed_primary_41171217
PublicationCentury 2000
PublicationDate 2025-Oct-31
PublicationDateYYYYMMDD 2025-10-31
PublicationDate_xml – month: 10
  year: 2025
  text: 2025-Oct-31
  day: 31
PublicationDecade 2020
PublicationPlace United States
PublicationPlace_xml – name: United States
PublicationTitle The Journal of hand surgery (American ed.)
PublicationTitleAlternate J Hand Surg Am
PublicationYear 2025
SSID ssj0001635
Score 2.4592128
SecondaryResourceType review_article
online_first
Snippet Prospective randomized controlled trials are widely regarded as the gold standard for evaluating therapeutic interventions. Although this model is appropriate...
SourceID proquest
pubmed
SourceType Aggregation Database
Index Database
Title Ten Reasons Why Prospective Randomized Studies in Surgery Are Flawed and Fundamentally Different From Drug Trials
URI https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/41171217
https://www.proquest.com/docview/3267676717
hasFullText
inHoldings 1
isFullTextHit
isPrint
link http://cvtisr.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/link/0/eLvHCXMwpZ3PS8MwFMeDOg9e_IG_5i8ieA02adp0JxFn8aBjzKm7lSxN3GRrt3ZT5l_vS9uxmwhS6KVtaJJH8kny3vchdOXoRiBjzydBYBjhhjtEMtclVIu-VDFTtFD7fH0UrVbQ6zXa1YZbXrlVLsfEYqCOU2X3yK8BM4S9qLiZTInNGmVPV6sUGuuo5gLKWKsWvZVaOLCGV-qlUgLcwqugmdK_62OQW90h5hU6p84viFlMNeHOf39yF21XkIlvS6vYQ2s62UfTrk5wR0sA7By_DRa4naXLOEvckUmcjoffOsaVZyEeJvi5jJmGgjQOR_ILnsJ7OLTRI2VSgNECN6sUKzMcZukYN7P5O-4WZn2AXsL77t0DqRIuEAUkJYjPYysfZwKAqD6lCtBAasWAMTxPGpcCS8RAMEzxODBaeoFwPeVrw3ymBHAnO0QbSZroY4SNAyUArHGtAi6l27dOcMqnilOjYUlTR5fLFozAoO0phUx0Os-jVRvW0VHZDdGkVN6IOKWCwiLq5A9fn6It27vlPHOGagbqrc_RpvqcDfPsorAUuLfaTz9xXMel
linkProvider ProQuest
openUrl ctx_ver=Z39.88-2004&ctx_enc=info%3Aofi%2Fenc%3AUTF-8&rfr_id=info%3Asid%2Fsummon.serialssolutions.com&rft_val_fmt=info%3Aofi%2Ffmt%3Akev%3Amtx%3Ajournal&rft.genre=article&rft.atitle=Ten+Reasons+Why+Prospective+Randomized+Studies+in+Surgery+Are+Flawed+and+Fundamentally+Different+From+Drug+Trials&rft.jtitle=The+Journal+of+hand+surgery+%28American+ed.%29&rft.au=Shin%2C+Alexander+Y&rft.au=de+Pinal%2C+Francisco&rft.date=2025-10-31&rft.issn=1531-6564&rft.eissn=1531-6564&rft_id=info:doi/10.1016%2Fj.jhsa.2025.09.009&rft.externalDBID=NO_FULL_TEXT
thumbnail_l http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/lc.gif&issn=1531-6564&client=summon
thumbnail_m http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/mc.gif&issn=1531-6564&client=summon
thumbnail_s http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/sc.gif&issn=1531-6564&client=summon